Forum

This episode rocked. This is classic comedy coming off the completely insane frontal lobes of Trey and Matt. Even in their deranged sleep-deprived off-the-cuff whatever they can pull off an episode of the highest quality (edit: granted, the T&M last minute magic doesn't work all the time, but this time it did.)

The post after mine is dumb. Don't read it.

A perfect example of what I've been talking about. The new "target audience": day-walking, rubbish-mumbling happy-go-lucky zombies, bringing South Park to the very bottom, to its own zombie-like state.

Alas, no use of preaching. Everythig's in vain now…

You sir, are a fag

Nice to meet you!

I'm well aware of south park's wrinkles (and increasingly lowbrow constituency as a result), but if you don't appreciate the spirit of this episode that means you never liked Trey and Mat's cartoon in the first place

Also cursefilter is wack.

Horrible episode i was very disappointed..
the whole story bored me to tears..the beginning was funny as sh*t, then after the cops came and randy was being all defensive, it went down hill everything was bad then alien thing, baby micgirrfuhbchsb, what his name was, the planet group,it was all lame!, horrible episode, just dreadful..sorry south park! i just expected more from you especially after fish sticks.

That was an interesting episode. It was a little wierd and probably the least funny of the season but it still had the classic South Park humour. Also, to all those saying they don't like the new episodes because they don't focus on the kids as much as they used to, you're ignorant (Mr. Jefferson, haha). Yes, the first few seasons featured the kids but they also had the adults in strong sub-plots. Randy, Sheila, and especially Mr. Garrison had plots centre around them in many episodes. For example ``Ike`s Wee Wee`` is a classic however it would have been better if it was made into two episodes, one about the kids and the briss and the other about Mr. Mackay doing drugs. I think M&T realized this and have gone towards a more sucessful one-plot format which means some episodes focus on the kids and others do not. ``Pinewood Derby`` would have been less enjoyable if a Cartman, Kyle, or Butters sub-plot was added.

f*ck you!!!

People are at such extremes for the love or hate of the episode.

No, I said that because he was insulting my friend PT.

You're an imperfect example of pseudo-intellectual hubris.



..as is the hope of ever losing your virginity.

I think Ike's Wee Wee is fine the way it is, thankyouverymuch. Splitting it into two episodes would have ruined it. And I don't completely mind adults getting screen time... I just want the kids to get plenty of time, too. That's the sort of thing I like seeing in an episode. If an episode has a plot involving the kids and another plot involving an adult, I always prefer the plot with the kids. Cherokee Hair Tampons makes a perfect example in my mind. Mr. Garrison kept that from being on my list of favorite episodes ever.

HOWEVER. My opinion is not the only valid opinion. If you would prefer Ike's Wee Wee as two episodes, that is perfectly fine. I'm sure that plenty of fans love seeing the adults. I'm sure that plenty of people loved the Cherokee Hair Tampons plot of Mr. Garrison writing his gay romance novel. We have many different views of South Park, and no one is ignorant for having an opinion you disagree with.

I have to say this... there are way to many people bitching about how this episode sucked. It is a TV show for god sakes.... Not all episodes are going to be to everyones liking. I am so sick of reading how M&T should do this or that!!!! If you don't like SP for what it is then watch family guy or something.... I have episodes that aren't my favorite and I have ones that I have watched over 100 times. But I bon't bitch about the ones that I don't like. I just don't watch them. I know your supposed to voice your opinion in this forum about post airing of the show.... but if your going to post something, aleast be constructive and stop whining like little 2 year olds!!!

Will never be remembered as a classic but I do like Randy as the lead character. It was a very simple idea by Matt & Trey with the addition of maybe Cartman it would have been better.

Yep. Just because people like something you don't, doesn't mean they are brain dead plebeians.
This episode seems to be big problem because people can't handle with any episodes that contain adults.
To those people I say: Why don't you go watch Peanuts, if you can't handle it? It's almost the same.